Why are my shoulders and muscles always so tense?
Have you ever had a massage, felt wonderfully relaxed afterwards, only to find that a few days later your shoulders are tight and uncomfortable again? Perhaps you regularly notice your shoulders creeping up toward your ears, and you’re always rubbing your neck because it feels so tense and stiff.
While massage therapy can be incredibly helpful for relieving muscular tension, another piece of the puzzle often gets overlooked: the nervous system and the body's response to stress.
Our muscles don't always become tight because we've been sitting at a desk for too long or sleeping in an awkward position. Emotional stress, prolonged worry, anxiety and an overloaded nervous system can all contribute to physical tension. In fact, the body can hold a surprising amount of tension even when we don't consciously feel stressed.
Understanding this connection opens up a different approach to managing recurring muscular tension – one that looks beyond the muscles themselves and considers the whole person.
How stress causes your muscles to tighten
When we experience stress, our nervous system activates a series of automatic responses designed to protect us. This is commonly known as the fight-or-flight response.
Thousands of years ago, this response helped us react to immediate physical threats. If we encountered danger, the body prepared us to run, fight or protect ourselves. Heart rate increases, breathing becomes faster, blood flow is redirected, and muscles become ready for action (tense!).
Our nervous system doesn't always distinguish well between physical danger and the psychological pressures of modern life and the daily stresses we face that aren't life-threatening. A demanding job, financial worries, relationship difficulties, constantly checking emails, rushing between commitments or simply feeling that there is too much to do can all activate the body's stress response.
As part of this response, muscles may become more active and remain partially contracted in preparation for action. The shoulders, neck, jaw and upper back are particularly common areas where people notice this tension.
Think about what happens when you're concentrating intensely, feeling anxious or dealing with a difficult situation. You might unknowingly:
- raise your shoulders towards your ears
- clench your jaw or grind your teeth
- hold your breath or breathe more shallowly
- tighten your neck and upper back.
These responses can become so habitual that you no longer notice them. Over time, repeated muscle activation and prolonged stress can contribute to persistent discomfort, stiffness, and a feeling of muscular tightness.
Why does tension keep coming back after a massage?
Massage works directly with the physical body. It can help reduce discomfort, encourage relaxation, improve the sensation of muscle mobility and provide a period of time where you can mentally switch off. However, if the underlying factors contributing to your muscle tension haven't changed, the same pattern may simply return.
Imagine spending an hour having your shoulders massaged and finally allowing those muscles to relax. You leave feeling lighter, looser and more comfortable, like all the tension has gone. But the following morning, you return to a stressful working environment, spend hours at a computer, skip lunch, drink several coffees and rush through the day worrying about everything you need to accomplish. Your nervous system may return to its previous state of heightened alertness, and your muscles may gradually begin to tighten again, bringing you back to square one.
This doesn't mean the massage hasn't worked. It means that massage may only be addressing one part of a much bigger picture. For people experiencing recurring tension, it can help to consider why the body keeps holding on to this protective muscular pattern.
Are you living with ongoing stress? Are you getting enough restorative sleep? Are you eating regularly and providing your nervous system with the nutrients it needs? Are you allowing yourself enough time to recover? These are some of the questions that a more holistic approach can explore.
The nervous system needs to feel safe before the body can fully relax. One of the most important things to understand about recurring muscle tension is that relaxation is not simply about physically loosening a muscle. The mental component is just as important in helping the nervous system move out of a state of alertness.
The autonomic nervous system has two main branches:
- The sympathetic nervous system: Responsible for the fight-or-flight response. It prepares the body for action and can increase muscular tension.
- The parasympathetic nervous system: Supports rest, digestion, recovery and relaxation. It helps the body return to a calmer state after stress.
Ideally, these two systems work together, allowing us to respond to challenges when necessary and then recover afterwards. However, when life involves prolonged stress, insufficient sleep, emotional strain or constant mental stimulation, we may spend too much time in a heightened state of alertness and not enough time recovering. This can contribute to a cycle in which stress increases muscle tension, muscle discomfort creates further stress, and the body struggles to settle.
Learning how to support the nervous system is therefore an important part of addressing recurring muscular tension. It is not about forcing yourself to relax or eliminating all stress from your life. It is about giving your body regular opportunities to recover and supporting this with diet, lifestyle changes and maybe herbal medicine too.
How diet and nutrition can influence muscle tension
When we think about muscular health, we often focus on stretching, exercise and massage. But nutrition also plays an important role in supporting normal muscle and nervous system function.
If your diet is inconsistent, you regularly skip meals, rely heavily on caffeine, or eat a highly processed diet, it may be worth looking at your nutritional habits.
Some nutrients are particularly relevant to normal muscle and nervous system function:
Magnesium
Magnesium is involved in normal muscle contraction and relaxation, nerve signalling and energy production. Inadequate magnesium intake can contribute to symptoms such as muscle cramps and weakness. Good dietary sources include pumpkin and sunflower seeds, almonds and cashews, dark green leaf vegetables, wholegrains, beans and lentils and dark chocolate.
Rather than automatically reaching for a supplement, consider whether your daily diet provides enough magnesium. Supplementation may be appropriate for some people, but it isn't a guaranteed solution for tight shoulders. Supplements can interact with medications, so it’s always best to check with a qualified practitioner or health professional before taking any supplements if you're also taking medication.
B vitamins
B vitamins support energy metabolism and normal nervous system function. Vitamin B12, in particular, is important for healthy nerve function. Sources include eggs, dairy products, fish, meat and fortified foods. People following vegan diets may need particular attention to B12 intake.
Omega-3 fatty acids
Omega-3 fats are involved in normal cell function and help regulate inflammatory processes. Oily fish such as salmon, sardines and mackerel are useful sources, while walnuts, chia seeds and flaxseeds provide plant-based omega-3s.
Protein and regular meals
Muscles need adequate protein to maintain and repair tissue. Eating regular, balanced meals can also help support consistent energy levels throughout the day. Make sure each meal contains a source of protein such as meat, fish, tofu, beans, lentils, nuts and seeds.
Hydration
Maintaining good hydration supports normal muscle function. Although drinking more water alone is unlikely to resolve chronic shoulder tension, dehydration shouldn't be overlooked.
The aim is to provide your body with the nutrients and hydration it needs to function well rather than searching for one particular food or supplement that will magically release tight muscles.
Can herbal medicine help with stress-related muscle tension?
Herbal medicine is another area worth exploring when muscular tension appears to have a strong connection with stress, anxiety or difficulty switching off. Rather than thinking of herbs as direct muscle relaxants, it may be more helpful to consider how certain herbs can support the factors contributing to tension, particularly restlessness, nervous tension and poor sleep.
Some herbs commonly used in traditional herbal practice include:
Lemon balm
Traditionally used as a calming herb, lemon balm is often considered when people experience nervous tension, restlessness or difficulty unwinding. It has a long history of traditional use.
Passionflower
Passionflower may be considered when mental overactivity and difficulty switching off are affecting sleep. Some preliminary research suggests possible benefits for anxiety, but the evidence remains limited.
Valerian
Traditionally used as a calming, sleep-supporting herb, valerian may be considered when poor sleep and restlessness contribute to difficulties with recovery.
Oat tops
Used traditionally in herbal medicine as a nourishing tonic for the nervous system, oat tops are sometimes included in formulations for people experiencing prolonged stress and mental exhaustion.
Herbs can interact with medication, and many are unsuitable during pregnancy, breastfeeding and certain medical conditions. This is why working with a qualified herbalist can be important, and a personalised herbal prescription may be more effective than simply buying a generic supplement marketed for sleep or stress.
Lifestyle changes that help your body release tension
Sometimes the most beneficial changes are also the simplest. Supporting the nervous system involves creating regular opportunities for the body to move out of its heightened state of alertness.
Here are some approaches worth incorporating into everyday life:
1. Practise slow, conscious breathing
When we're stressed, breathing often becomes faster and shallower. We may unconsciously hold our breath or breathe predominantly into the upper chest.
2. Move regularly throughout the day
Sitting at a desk for hours can contribute to neck and shoulder discomfort, particularly when combined with stress. Gentle movement helps prevent prolonged static postures and supports normal joint and muscle function. Even taking short walking breaks may help.
3. Prioritise restorative sleep
Sleep is essential for physical recovery and emotional regulation. If you're regularly sleeping poorly, your body may have fewer opportunities to recover from the demands of the day. Practice sleep hygiene and try taking a warm bath before bed. Some people find that smelling lavender helps them relax, so maybe try adding a few drops of lavender essential oil to a tissue and leaving it under your pillow.
4. Be mindful of caffeine
Caffeine stimulates the central nervous system and can increase feelings of alertness, restlessness or anxiety in some people. If you're already feeling stressed or wired, several coffees throughout the day may not be helping. Consider reducing your intake gradually, particularly later in the day, and notice whether this makes a difference to your sleep and overall sense of tension.
5. Make space for genuine recovery
One of the biggest challenges of modern life is that many people rarely allow themselves to stop. Even when we're physically resting, our minds may still be working through emails, planning tomorrow or worrying about unfinished tasks. Recovery involves more than simply sitting on the sofa. It means giving yourself permission to step away from constant demands.
Why a naturopathic approach may be worth considering
If your shoulders or muscles are constantly tense and the discomfort keeps returning despite regular massage, it may be worth looking at the bigger picture with a qualified naturopath or herbalist.
Rather than focusing solely on the tight muscles, they can explore the underlying lifestyle and nutritional factors that may be contributing to your body's stress response. This can also work well when combined with manual treatments such as massage, acupuncture, exercises and other relaxation treatments.
The aim is to support the body's natural ability to regulate stress, rest, and recover, while addressing factors that may be contributing to recurring muscular tension. Instead of repeatedly treating the symptom, naturopathy offers an opportunity to explore what your body might need to help break the cycle of stress and tension.
References
Cefalì et al. (2025): Effects of breathing exercises on neck pain management: A systematic review with meta-analysis.
Basco-López et al. (2025): Relaxation techniques in chronic nonspecific neck pain: A systematic review and meta-analysis.
Mathews et al. (2024): Clinical efficacy and tolerability of lemon balm (Melissa officinalis L.) in psychological well-being: A review.
Lee et al. (2020): Effects of Passiflora incarnata Linnaeus on polysomnographic sleep parameters in subjects with insomnia disorder: A double-blind randomized placebo-controlled study.
Shinjyo et al. (2020): Valerian root in treating sleep problems and associated disorders: A systematic review and meta-analysis.
Find the holistic therapist for you
All therapists are verified professionals